The protective surfaces of bacteria are comprised of polysaccharides and are involved in host invasion and colonization, host immune system evasion, and antibacterial resistance. A major barrier to our fundamental understanding of these complex surface polysaccharides lies in the tremendous diversity in glycan composition among bacterial species. The polyisoprenoid bactoprenyl phosphate (or undecaprenyl phosphate) is an essential lipid carrier necessary for early stages of glycopolymer assembly. Because of the ubiquity of bactoprenyl phosphate in these critical processes, molecular probes appended to this lipid carrier simplify identification of enzymatic roles during polysaccharide bioassembly. A limited number of these probes exist in the literature or have been assessed with such pathways, and the limits of their use are not currently known. Herein, we devise an efficient method for producing fluorescently modified bactoprenyl probes. We further expand our previous efforts utilizing 2-nitrileaniline and additionally prepare nitrobenzoxadizol-tagged bactoprenyl phosphate for the first time. We then assess the enzyme promiscuity of these two probes utilizing four well-characterized initiating phosphoglycosyltransferases: CPS2E (Streptococcus pneumoniae), WbaP (Salmonella enterica), WecA (Escherichia coli), and WecP (Aeromonas hydrophilia). Both probes serve as substrates for these enzymes and could be readily used to investigate a wide range of bacterial glycoassembly pathways. Interestingly, we have also identified unique solubility requirements for the nitrobenzoxadizol moiety for efficient enzymatic utilization that was not observed for the 2-nitrileaniline.