Nanoformulations, prodrugs, and targeted therapies are among the most intensively investigated approaches to new cancer therapeutics. Human ferritin has been used extensively as a nanocarrier for the delivery of drugs and imaging agents to cancerous tumor cells both in vitro and in vivo. We report exploitation of the native properties of ferritin, which can be co-loaded with simple forms of iron (FeOOH) and arsenic (arsenate) in place of the native phosphate. The As(III) form arsenic trioxide has been successfully used to treat one blood cancer, but has so far proven too systemically toxic for use on solid tumors in the clinic. The As(V) form, arsenate, on the other hand, while much less systemically toxic upon bolus injection has also proven ineffective for cancer therapy. We extended the C-terminal ends of the human ferritin subunits with a tumor cell receptor targeting peptide and loaded this modified ferritin with ~ 800 arsenates and ~ 1100 irons. Our results demonstrate targeting and uptake of the iron, arsenate-loaded modified human ferritin by breast cancer cells. At the same arsenic levels, the cytotoxicity of the iron, arsenate-loaded human ferritin was equivalent to that of free arsenic trioxide and much greater than that of free arsenate. The iron-only loaded human ferritin was not cytotoxic at the highest achievable doses. The results are consistent with the receptor-targeted human ferritin delivering arsenate as a reductively activated 'prodrug'. This targeted delivery could be readily adapted to treat other types of solid tumor cancers.