Cellulolytic fungi usually have multiple genes for C1-oxidizing auxiliary activity 9 (AA9) lytic polysaccharide monooxygenases (LPMOs) in their genomes, but their potential functional differences are less understood. In this study, two C1-oxidizing AA9 LPMOs, SbLPMO9A and SbLPMO9B, were identified from Sordaria brevicollis, and their differences, particularly in terms of thermostability, reducing agent specificity, and synergy with cellulase, were explored. The two enzymes exhibited weak binding to cellulose and intolerance to hydrogen peroxide. Their oxidative activity was influenced by cellulose crystallinity and surface morphology, and both enzymes tended to oxidize celluloses of lower crystallinity and high surface area. Comparably, SbLPMO9A had much better thermostability than SbLPMO9B, which may be attributed to the presence of a carbohydrate binding module 1 (CBM1)-like sequence at its C-terminus. In addition, the two enzymes exhibited different specificities and responsivities toward electron donors. SbLPMO9A and SbLPMO9B were able to boost the catalytic efficiency of endoglucanase I (EGI) on physically and chemically pretreated substrates but with different degrees of synergy. Substrate- and enzyme-specific synergism was observed by comparing the synergistic action of SbLPMO9A or SbLPMO9B with commercial Celluclast 1.5L on three kinds of cellulosic substrates. On regenerated amorphous cellulose and PFI (Papirindustriens Forskningsinstitut)-fibrillated bleached eucalyptus pulp, SbLPMO9B showed a higher synergistic effect than SbLPMO9A, while on delignified wheat straw, the synergistic effect of SbLPMO9A was higher than that of SbLPMO9B. On account of its excellent thermostability and boosting effect on the enzymatic hydrolysis of delignified wheat straw, SbLPMO9A may have high application potential in biorefineries for lignocellulosic biomass. KEY POINTS: • C1-oxidizing SbLPMO9A displayed higher thermostability than SbLPMO9B, probably due to the presence of a CBM1-like module. • The oxidative activity of the two SbLPMO9s on celluloses increased with decreasing cellulose crystallinity or increasing beating degree. • The two SbLPMO9s boosted the catalytic efficiency of cellulase, but the synergistic effect was substrate- and enzyme-specific.