Type I CRISPR-Cas systems provide prokaryotes with protection from parasitic genetic elements by cleaving foreign DNA. In addition, they impact bacterial physiology by regulating pathogenicity and virulence, making them key players in adaptability and evolution. The signature nuclease Cas3 is a phosphodiesterase belonging to the HD-domain metalloprotein superfamily. By directing specific metal incorporation, we map a promiscuous metal ion cofactor profile for Cas3 from (). Cas3 affords significant ssDNA cleavage with four homo-dimetal centers (Fe, Co, Mn, and Ni), while the diferrous form is the most active and likely biologically relevant in vivo. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy and Mössbauer spectroscopy show that the diiron cofactor can access three redox forms, while the diferrous form can be readily obtained with mild reductants. We further employ EPR and Mössbauer on Fe-enriched proteins to establish that Cas3″ enzymes harbor a dinuclear cofactor, which was not previously confirmed. We demonstrate that the ancillary His ligand is critical for efficient ssDNA cleavage but not for diiron assembly or small molecule hydrolysis. We further explore the ability of Cas3 to hydrolyze cyclic mononucleotides and show that Cas3 hydrolyzes 2'3'-cAMP with catalytic efficiency comparable to that of the conserved virulence factor A (CvfA), an HD-domain protein hydrolyzing 2'3'-cylic phosphodiester bonds at RNA 3'-termini. Because this CvfA activity is linked to virulence regulation, Cas3 may also utilize 2'3'-cAMP hydrolysis as a possible molecular route to control virulence.