Strong, psychedelic indolethylamines (IAAs) are typically present in trace amounts in the majority of species, but they build up significantly in the skin of amphibian toads, especially N-methylated 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) analogues. However, there is no pertinent research on the investigation of indoleamine N-methyltransferase (INMT) in amphibians, nor is there any adequate information on the key amino acids that influence the activity of known INMTs from other species. Herein, we focused on Bufo toad INMT (BINMT) for the first time and preliminarily identified BINMT 1 from the transcriptomes of Bufo gargarizans active on tryptamine, 5-HT, and N-methyl-5-HT. We established the enzyme kinetic characteristics of BINMT 1 and identified the essential amino acids influencing its activity via molecular docking and site-directed mutagenesis. Subsequently, we carried out sequence alignment and phylogenetic tree analysis on 43 homologous proteins found in the genome of B. gargarizans with BINMT 1 as the probe and selected seven of them for protein expression and activity assays. It was found that only three proteins possessing the highest similarity to BINMT 1 had INMT activity. Our research unveils the binding residues of BINMT for 5-HT analogues for the first time and initiates the study of INMTs in amphibian toads, serving as a tentative reference for further study of BINMT and providing insight into the comprehension of BINMT's catalytic mechanism and its role in the biosynthesis of 5-HT analogues in Bufo toads. It also contributes to the expansion of the INMT library to help explore and explain interspecies evolution in the future.